The volatility in production, futures prices, basis, and spreads of the last few years have caused many of us to abandon the idea of a “normal” merchandising environment, or at least change the definition of “normal” to mean a volatile market. Grain merchandisers have had their share of stress and risk, but volatility has also created opportunity, leading to some of the best margins ever. As much as things have changed, and require us to change with them, navigating this environment successfully also demands that basis traders rely on some of the basic skills they started with.
What is the same?
The need for discipline All the things you learned in the early days of your basis trading education (whether that was 30 days or 30 years ago) are more important than ever. Things like:
Keeping your position hedged at all times
Daily routines and processes to double check your positions and know where you stand
Setting goals and having a plan
Being able to quote firm numbers to buyers and farmers
Avoiding kooky contracts with buyers or farmers and other rules of discipline are more important now than they have ever been. Discipline and focus are the foundation on which all opportunity is built.
The tools to generate margins You still have only three tools to generate your grain margins – buy basis, sell basis, and spreads. Efficient management of these three tools will still produce profitable results.
The power of fellowship It can be easy, especially in a volatile market, to feel isolated. Getting together with fellow merchants in person, on the phone, or online has always been powerful and it is even more so now. At the very least you will know that everyone is facing the same challenges, more likely you will find answers to your challenges and help other find answers to theirs.
What is different?
Awareness is no longer optional For many years, price, basis, and spreads moved in small enough ranges and predictable enough patterns that it was possible to be consistently profitable, if not highly successful, running a grain business on autopilot. That is most certainly not the case any longer. It is hard to be successful as a part-time basis trader. Things move too quickly and opportunities arise and disappear in a flash, often at different times than they used to. Success demands a high level of awareness.
Timing is flexible We are learning that in a volatile environment, things can and do happen at any time. For example, it used to be a truism that you bought fall crops in the fall and sold them in the winter, spring, and summer. In many cases this year, the time to buy fall crops was a year before harvest, and the time to sell them was right during the middle of harvest. This presents a mental struggle for many. After all, harvest is the time to buy, not the time to sell, right? You must be mentally agile in this environment. Being enslaved to old habits or ideas of the “right time” to do things will lead to missed opportunities or worse.
Changing markets demand changing practices As the marketplace becomes more global and new buyers emerge in unexpected places, you must be flexible in your approach to merchandising. You may find yourself selling crops you normally hold on to, or holding on to crops you normally sell. Old standby buyers may become irrelevant as new buyers emerge, or you may deal with a dozen buyers instead of one or two. Most of us do not find change comfortable, but this environment demands of us the willingness to change and pursue opportunity where it is, not where we want it to be.
Cash is King As grain prices have increased and stayed high, so has the need to manage capital and cash flow in the grain business. A good relationship with a banker who understands your business is a great start, but it takes more than that. Basis trading skills, a high level of awareness, and the ability to be flexible will allow you to line up your capital with the best opportunities. There must be a conscious effort to control money needs and focus on the areas of highest return.
Focus is vital As price, spreads, and basis gyrate, it is tempting to constantly ask “why?” The danger of this question is that as you gather information, news, and opinions about local and global happenings, there is a high likelihood of “analysis paralysis.” None of us are capable of processing all available information into a coherent strategy, so as information grows, the ability to make decisions shrinks. We must learn to stay focused on the things we can control and exercise a high level of control over those things. When focus on a few simple things is combined with awareness of opportunity, money management, and the mental flexibility to act whenever opportunity presents itself, all the other “stuff” in the marketplace will take care of itself or fade into irrelevancy.
As we deal with the challenges of a volatile market, it’s exciting to realize that while the execution and timing may change, the same skills that we have been using in calmer markets will help navigate us through volatile ones as well. We just need to stay focused, stay disciplined, and pay attention.